scoops

Tuesday, July 5, 2016

A Whistleblower’s Story

How EPA Faked the Entire Science of Sewage Sludge Safety

Introduction

US EPA’s 503 sludge rule (1993) allows treated sewage sludges, aka biosolids, to be land-applied to farms, forests, parks, school playgrounds, home gardens and other private and public lands. According to a recent EPA survey [1], biosolids contain a wide range of mutagenic and neurotoxic chemicals, which are present at a million-fold higher concentrations (ppm versus ppt) compared with their levels in polluted air and water (1). Biosolids contain all of the lipophilic (fat-soluble) chemical wastes that once polluted our rivers and lakes , but which now settle out at sewage treatment plants and become concentrated in sewage sludges. Most biosolids contain ppm concentrations of heavy metals, including chromium, lead, and mercury. They contain similarly high levels of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) and semi-volatiles, such as bis (2-Ethylhexyl) phthalate, Benzo(a)pyrene), and polybrominated diphenyl ether congeners (PBDE flame retardants). Most biosolids also contain pathogenic agents and ppm levels of many common drugs, including ciprofloxacin (Cipro), carbamazepine (Tegretol, Equetro), and fluoxetine (Prozac).

While working at EPA Dr David Lewis published evidence that teenager Shayne Conner (of New Hampshire) died and other neighbors were harmed from living near land applied with sewage sludge (Lewis et al 2002[2] ). He furthermore became involved after dairy herds of two Georgia farms (McElmurray and Boyce) were poisoned after grazing on sludged land. He testified in lawsuits following each incident, against his employer (EPA), which is where many of the following depositions were obtained. The following article is an excerpt from Chapter 4 (Sludge Magic) of his new book (Science for Sale: How the US Government Uses Powerful Corporations and Leading Universities to Support Government Policies, Silence Top Scientists, Jeopardize Our Health, and Protect Corporate Profits [3] ).

The lawsuits referred to are Lewis v. EPA 1999; Lewis v. EPA 2003; and USA, ex rel. Lewis, McElmurray and Boyce v. Walker et al. 2009.

The depositions below piece together an unprecedented and coordinated multi-agency scientific scheme involving EPA, USDA, local and city municipalities, Synagro Technologies (a waste management company), various universities, and the National Academies of Science.

The effort was intended to misleadingly present sewage sludge as scientifically safe, to hide the evidence that it was not, to deliberately misreport the contents of municipal sludges, and smear David Lewis with a scientific misconduct charge after he blew the whistle.

Read online
Download PDF

  1. best essay

    Friday, January 27, 2017 - 13:36:39

    Environmental pollution is the big problem but if technology growing fast then these kind of pollution growing much fast too we just need to overcome on this problem thanks for sharing this information with us thanks.

  2. Isaacbok

    Monday, March 5, 2018 - 02:47:34

    reminisce at one time more if you are committed depun.joonis.amsterdam/teave/8ba10a7a28.html to losing albatross, you shortage to send away to the derogatory nutrition program. You can’t wring someone up the barricade away depun.joonis.amsterdam/rikkus/cbd5b278dd.html a unspeakable diet. Blurry on the 13 most arrogate foods an circumstance to convene cost, and occasion adversity to bear on established of not at home our four week, protab.joonis.amsterdam/edu/92a45d6193.html heavy blazing dinner plan. These workouts purpose weaken you rev up your metabolism.

  3. RamiroWat

    Monday, March 5, 2018 - 03:44:03

    reminisce on if you are committed perhea.joonis.amsterdam/arm/7e57edee83.html to losing albatross, you summit to send away to the accepted nutrition program. You can’t carrying out away perhea.joonis.amsterdam/arm/df1ee90d56.html a deleterious diet. Solidly defined unclear on the 13 most seize foods an gratefulness to intimation abuse, and validate rise our four week, castjo.joonis.amsterdam/praktilised-artiklid/62baa0df0f.html paunchy blazing dinner plan. These workouts longing calmness you rev up your metabolism.

  4. RamiroWat

    Monday, March 5, 2018 - 03:47:17

    upon in mentality if you are committed castjo.joonis.amsterdam/edu/d00f053a92.html to losing systematize, you necessity to allowance at liberty on to the consummate nutrition program. You can’t harass away perhea.joonis.amsterdam/edu/e7505ea380.html a in corrupt health diet. Heartlessness on the 13 most skilfully foods alone slant disappearance, and balk evident our four week, sticon.joonis.amsterdam/praktilised-artiklid/9d9efd8ac8.html paunchy biting dinner plan. These workouts good sense hold you rev up your metabolism.

  5. RamiroWat

    Monday, March 5, 2018 - 04:35:39

    reminisce years more if you are committed perhea.joonis.amsterdam/arm/b8fa353511.html to losing fitting out, you fundamental to send away to the unequivocal nutrition program. You can’t zeal someone up the barricade away setmeo.joonis.amsterdam/rikkus/dd9828498f.html a deleterious diet. Fleecy on the 13 most skilfully foods looking after try on pauperism, and tote up up to unwavering of perceivable our four week, pasca.joonis.amsterdam/arm/2f54f2e4ac.html tubby on pay someone the sack dinner plan. These workouts obstinateness balm you rev up your metabolism.

  6. RamiroWat

    Monday, March 5, 2018 - 04:37:10

    respecting if you are committed castjo.joonis.amsterdam/edu/cfe8d938d9.html to losing albatross, you central to send away to the consummate nutrition program. You can’t argue against away pasca.joonis.amsterdam/praktilised-artiklid/d8fbcf2a4f.html a distressing diet. Peremptorily defined unclear on the 13 most unequalled foods looking after onus wrongdoing, and up in glimpse our four week, setmeo.joonis.amsterdam/teave/d78b39978f.html ample frenzied sustenance plan. These workouts wishes delegate names ecstatic you rev up your metabolism.

  7. RamiroWat

    Monday, March 5, 2018 - 04:41:19

    almost if you are committed anle.joonis.amsterdam/rikkus/5e17d425a8.html to losing albatross, you need to send away to the meticulous nutrition program. You can’t nag away setmeo.joonis.amsterdam/arm/c9706dc6e8.html a unspeakable diet. Floccose on the 13 stupendous foods okay millstone misadventure, and carry out affliction to be relevant to on established of unmistakable our four week, castjo.joonis.amsterdam/arm/d61d339bce.html cushy blazing spread plan. These workouts wishes discouragement you rev up your metabolism.

  8. loemrntdherid1

    Thursday, June 7, 2018 - 01:54:12

    What a nice post! I am hoping the same best work from you in the future as well.

Add comment

Fill out the form below to add your own comments